DENVER BRONCOS

New favorite emerges to select J.J. McCarthy in NFL Draft

Mar 18, 2024, 5:26 PM

Sean Payton may have found who he wants to be the next quarterback of the Denver Broncos but will Michigan’s J.J. McCarthy still be on the board when the Orange and Blue select?

Oddsmakers say the Broncos aren’t going to get McCarthy with their No. 12 pick in the 2024 NFL Draft. Instead, sharps have now made the Minnesota Vikings the favorite to land the Wolverine after it was made public that he would have a private workout for the Twin Cities team next week. The Vikings are slated to pick No. 11, in part because the Broncos beat them 21-20 in Week 11 this past fall. In fact, Denver now has worse odds to end up with McCarthy than two teams who select in front of the Broncos, and the Patriots are also a candidate and they too pick before Denver.

Odds to draft J.J McCarthy

Minnesota: – 115
New York Giants: +350
Denver: +430
New England: +900
Las Vegas: +1600

McCarthy at Michigan

McCarthy seems to fit the profile second-year Broncos coach Sean Payton is looking for. The 6-foot-3 Chicagoland native is solid pocket passer and won a ton of games including the national title while in Ann Arbor.

McCarthy was simply pedestrian in the national title game, completing 10-18 passes for 140 yards and zero touchdowns. He didn’t throw an interception, but the ground game carried the Wolverines with four total touchdowns.

On the season, McCarthy threw for nearly 3,000 yards to go along with 22 TDs and just four picks. Michigan finished a perfect 15-0.


Who are the Broncos taking at No. 12? Get all the latest mock drafts here!


McCarthy to the Minnesota Vikings?

The Vikings are all of a sudden in need of a quarterback after six-year Kirk Cousins starter chose to sign a big deal in Atlanta last week. The Broncos were also interested in Cousins. This put the Broncos and Vikings into a bidding war for Sam Darnold. The former top pick of the Jets inked with the NFC North team. Meanwhile, Josh Dobbs who started that key game in Week 11 against Denver, signed with the 49ers on Monday, leaving the Vikings again short on quarterback options. And Darnold himself has bounced between a starter and backup and could just be a placeholder for McCarthy.

Quarterback purgatory in Denver?

The Broncos orchestrated a giant trade and extension to get and keep Russell Wilson in Colorado. He’s now a Steeler before that contract even kicked in as his two years with the Broncos went awry. The Broncos are limited on picks and salary and are attempting to find somebody to pair with Jarrett Stidham in the quarterback room. The easy solution would be a rookie but because of Wilson’s five-game win streak midseason last year including the game against Minny, Denver is outside of premium draft position. The Broncos are likely to see the top names, and possibly their guy in McCarthy off the board before being able to pick.

Denver Broncos

Ashton Jeanty Broncos draft...

Will Petersen

Ashton Jeanty specifically mentions the Broncos as ‘talking to him the most’

"Really, the Denver Broncos, they was heavy on me," Ashton Jeanty said in a recent interview about teams that spoke with him at the NFL Combine

6 hours ago

Cam MIller, North Dakota State QB, visited with the Broncos...

Andrew Mason

For Broncos, isn’t it nice to have the quarterback riddle answered?

The best part of this year's pre-draft process for the Denver Broncos has been not having to worry about quarterback.

22 hours ago

Denver Broncos Power Rankings Courtland Sutton...

DenverSports.com Staff

Report: Sutton believes contract talks with Broncos are ‘working in right direction’

Courtland Sutton seems optimistic that he and the Broncos can work out a contract extension to settle his situation for the long term.

3 days ago

Shedeur Sanders...

Andrew Mason

Shedeur Sanders isn’t on Broncos’ radar — but he could impact their draft

Just because the Broncos aren't looking for a quarterback doesn't mean Shedeur Sanders' status might not affect their draft plans.

5 days ago

John Elway...

James Merilatt

Milestone No. 1: The Broncos finally get to hoist the Lombardi Trophy

After 37 years of waiting, including four seasons that ended in the ultimate disappointment, the Broncos were finally able to win the Super Bowl

5 days ago

(Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images)...

James Merilatt

Milestone No. 2: Tebow Mania becomes the biggest story in sports

During a six-game winning streak that turned the 2-5 Broncos into a playoff contender, Tim Tebow became the biggest story in all of sports

6 days ago

New favorite emerges to select J.J. McCarthy in NFL Draft